Plutocracy
India’s new gene is called plutocracy
4 min read . 04 Oct 2017Rajrishi SinghalIndia has been called a plutocracy for its manifest disposition towards the rich and the powerful
The stampede at Mumbai’s Elphinstone Road train station last week, which claimed 27 lives, holds up a mirror to India’s policy bias towards the rich and powerful. Many people (including this columnist) impulsively tweeted about the government’s penchant for bullet trains versus apathy towards basic infrastructure for daily commuters; the tragedy, though, showcases a much larger malaise, one that has been patronized by successive governments.
The catastrophe can be sourced to how politicians and industrialists colluded to develop Lower Parel, an erstwhile textile mill neighbourhood that has now been converted into malls, offices, TV studios, restaurants and residential blocks by tweaking rules and with complete disregard for the livelihood of its original residents, public transport or traffic growth.
All cities around the world redevelop and rejuvenate urban areas but do so with some thought to forward and backward linkages. The rules designed to facilitate Lower Parel’s development had a sole objective: to help mill owners unlock land value without any thought of how millions of office workers and service providers would enter and exit the area. End result: the loss of lives at the Elphinstone Road station.
There is a name for this. India has often been called a plutocracy for its manifest disposition towards the rich and the powerful. Plutocracy, in short, can be defined as rule by the wealthy and the powerful, where policies and systems are designed to deliver greater benefits to the wealthy and powerful. Consequently, plutocracy eats away at the core of any democratic system.
A recent paper by Lucas Chancel and Thomas Piketty shows how India’s average real income growth accelerated post-2000. Simultaneously, it also shows how the top 10% grew at a much faster rate than the average, while income growth of the balance 90% fell below average. While the authors avoid offering any conclusions about the impact of economic reforms on inequality or poverty in India, their findings point to an uncomfortable truth: Post the 1980s, when the process of economic reforms began, the top 1% in India have seen their incomes and wealth grow at a much faster rate than the balance 99%.
Increasing wealth concentration among the rich is corroborated by Credit Suisse’s Global Wealth Report 2016: India’s top 1%, which owned 36.8% of the country’s wealth in 2000, now owns close to 58% of the wealth (the global average is 50%). An Oxfam 2017 report showed that 57 Indian billionaires own as much as the bottom 70% of the population.
Another paper by Dilip M. Nachane and Aditi Chaubal (goo.gl/gxLcwd) finds a plutocratic bias in the way India’s consumer price index (CPI) is constructed, by attaching greater weightage to items of expenditure consumed by higher income groups. This has enormous implications for policy design, especially when the Reserve Bank of India has selected CPI as its chosen benchmark for inflation targeting.
Plutocracy is also characterized by suborning of national institutions. Public-private partnerships (PPPs) are perhaps the best examples of how this financing mode was used to reward private sector partners with state resources (including valuable real estate) with the government (or government-owned institutions) shouldering the bulk of project risk.
For example, in airport PPPs, private partners have been treating public land as private property. Of course, there were many PPPs that failed because of bureaucratic stasis or other extraneous reasons but the fundamental flaw in Indian PPPs was hard to miss.
Plutocracy can also be identified in the way institutions behave. India’s largest commercial bank, the State Bank of India (SBI), decided to step outside its sandbox and experiment with new revenue sources: it decided to penalize customers who failed to maintain the monthly average balance in their savings bank account.
This example was quickly emulated by some other private banks. SBI’s haste and poor planning in announcing and executing the new revenue stream came back to bite it: a torrent of protests has forced the SBI to exempt pensioners and minors (whose accounts typically empty out soon after money is deposited) and reduce the penalty amounts for other depositors.
Policy haste, without thinking through the consequences, is quite commonplace in India, whether in government or in institutions.
The SBI example shows how policy moves when it does not take into account customer profile, feasibility options or its impact on various income groups. Demonetization is another example of how an autarchic policy decision affected livelihoods for a wide spectrum of the population.
What’s more worrying is the bias in policy towards those with more money, power or both. Typically, by the time public policy emerges from drawing board to final design, political and business influences shape its biases.
It is instructive to note the role of politicians in plutocracy. The Supreme Court recently upbraided the Centre for the rapid—and, in some cases, inexplicable—rise in politicians’ assets. Interestingly, when one of their own was banned from flying for perpetrating violence against airline staffers, parliamentarians banded together to get him a reprieve.
On the rebound, though, the aviation ministry has now empowered airlines to unilaterally ban “unruly" passengers, without offering citizens any means of contesting the one-sided rule. The odds are always stacked against ordinary citizens in a plutocracy.
Rajrishi Singhal is a consultant and former editor of a leading business newspaper. His Twitter handle is @rajrishisinghal.
Comments are welcome at views@livemint.com
Click here to read the Mint ePaper mint is now on Telegram. Join mint channel in your Telegram and stay updated
White House acknowledges Trump's condition had been worse than revealed
2 min read . 05:49 PM IST- White House Chief of Staff Mark Meadows says doctors recommended Trump to go to hospital after seeing he had a fever and his blood oxygen level dropped rapidly
- 'He's made unbelievable improvements from yesterday morning when I know a number of us, the doctor and I, were very concerned,' Meadows adds
Govt plans to administer covid-19 vaccines to 20-25 crore Indians by July
2 min read . 03:38 PM IST- The Centre, along with states, is also preparing a list of priority population groups, especially frontline health workers, who would receive immunisation shots,
GST Council meet likely on Mon; non-BJP states to oppose Centre's borrowing plan
3 min read . 12:52 PM IST- In the current fiscal, the states are staring at a staggering ₹2.35 lakh crore Goods and Services Tax (GST) revenue shortfall
- Sources said in the 42nd meeting of the Council on October 5, opposition-ruled states would object to the Centre's borrowing options
Your morning ritual now travels with you!
Try Mint E-paperRift in NDA as LJP says will not contest Bihar elections with JDU
2 min read . 06:24 PM IST- The decision was taken at the LJP’s parliamentary board meeting chaired by party president Chirag Paswan on Sunday. The meeting was earlier scheduled for Saturday but had to be postponed as Ram Vilas Paswan underwent heart surgery
Won't contest Bihar polls under JD(U) due to ideological differences, says LJP
3 min read . 05:03 PM IST- LJP said that while it would field candidates against JD(U), it would not do so in seats where the BJP is contesting
- The Bihar assembly polls will be held in three phases on October 28, November 3, and November 7
Will throw farm laws in waste basket when Congress comes to power: Rahul Gandhi
3 min read . 04:30 PM IST- 'I am not saying there are no shortcomings in the system, of course there are and there is a need to reform the system. But there is no need to destroy the entire system because farmers will have no protection left'
Markets to shift focus to Trump recovery and corporate earnings
3 min read . 03:32 PM ISTDonald Trump’s infection fallout could of course keep the markets choppy for some time. But given the liquidity gush, stocks may start to recover along with a Trump recovery
India, China may hold next round of military talks on 12 October
3 min read . 02:09 PM IST- The composition of the Indian delegation for the 12 October talks could remain the same as that of 21 September when two sides met at Moldo on the Chinese side of the LAC
Economic recovery gained momentum in September, says finance ministry
3 min read . 01:30 PM IST- The finance ministry said as intermittent lockdowns cease, containment zones become fewer and smooth operation of supply chains resumes, a fall in retail inflation may boost personal consumption expenditure
WhatsApp new features on anvil: Always mute option, media guidelines, and more
2 min read . 04:53 PM ISTSeveral reports have been suggesting a slew of features that WhatsApp is currently working on and which are likely to be available in the coming days
Biden leads Covid-hit Trump nationally by 10 points, largest in a month: Poll
3 min read . 04:08 PM IST65% Americans agreed that 'if President Trump had taken coronavirus more seriously, he probably would not have been infected', says a Reuters/Ipsos poll
Coronavirus vaccine: 'Govt looking for 500 mn doses for 25 cr people'
5 min read . 03:07 PM IST- 'There is a high-level expert body going into all aspects of vaccines. Our target would be to receive and utilise 400 to 500 mn doses covering approximately 25 crore people by July 2021,' says Union Health Minister
- States have been advised to send details of priority population groups by end of October, says Vardhan
Fund-starved Andhra Pradesh govt explores floating casinos off Vizag coast
3 min read . 03:07 PM IST- The state government has reached out to the Centre and is looking to promote tourism on the lines of what Goa has done on the Mandovi river
Ensuring Covid-19 vaccine for all govt's utmost priority: Harsh Vardhan
2 min read . 02:02 PM IST- 'The govt is working round the clock to ensure that there is a fair and equitable distribution of vaccines,' Harsh Vardhan said
- India's coronavirus caseload went past 65 lakh mark today, according to the Union Health Ministry data
Government weighs legal options in Vodafone tax arbitration case
4 min read . 10:22 AM IST- Finance Ministry sources said the government will decide on challenging the award before a court in Singapore - which was the seat of the arbitration, after taking legal opinion
- The cost implication in the case is limited to having to pay ₹85 crore to Vodafone in legal cost
Donald Trump testing positive for covid-19, a warning sign for Beijing
2 min read . 02:06 PM IST- Even at the First Presidential Debate, Trump said that it 'was China's fault' adding that 'it never should have happened'
- Blair Brandt, a Donald Trump campaign fundraiser further attacked the Chinese Communist Party saying that it 'has biologically attacked our President'
From cooked food to plexiglass screens: How Maha plans to reopen restaurants
1 min read . 12:03 PM IST- Maharashtra govt issues guidelines for restaurants, hotels and eateries which are set to reopen from tomorrow
- As per the guidelines, face masks will be mandatory, except while eating
Schools in Delhi to remain closed till 31 October
1 min read . 01:18 PM IST- The Delhi government had earlier extended the school closure till October 5
- Universities and schools across the country have been closed since March 16 when the Centre announced a countrywide classroom shutdown as part of measures to contain the spread of the covid-19
Covid-19 cases in India breach 65-lakh mark: 10 points
2 min read . 01:09 PM IST- Coronavirus update: The total coronavirus cases mounted to 65,49,373
- The United States is the world’s worst-affected country followed by India and Brazil
Why Biden would start tax increases at $400,000 a year
5 min read . 01:10 PM ISTDemocrat’s plan would affect only about 1.8% of households, sparing the middle class, but constrain policy choices
Know when your money will get doubled - the rule of 72
2 min read . 12:36 PM IST- If you want to double your money in five years, your investments should grow at around 14.4% per year
- Kisan Vikas Patra will double your money in 10 years at current interest rate
Burj Khalifa builder Arabtec confirms liquidation
1 min read . 12:27 PM IST- The announcement comes after 'weeks of intense speculation' over the entity's future
- In a general assembly meeting the stakeholders voted 'discontinue with the company and dissolve it due to its untenable financial situation'
NCB's KPS Malhotra, investigating drug angle in Sushants case, tests Covid +ve
1 min read . 12:44 PM IST- KPS Malhotra, deputy director in the Narcotics Control Bureau (NCB), has tested positive for the novel coronavirus
- NCB is probing the drug-angle in Sushant Singh Rajput’s death case
Donald Trump said to be improving but next 48 hours 'critical'
8 min read . 09:58 AM IST- Thursday no oxygen. None at this moment
- And yesterday with the team, while we were all here, he was not on oxygen, Conley said
How to create a regular income stream with fixed deposits?
2 min read . 11:40 AM IST- Bank FD laddering is a technique which involves buying multiple FDs maturing on different time periods
- Some corporate FDs offer a Systematic Deposit Plan (SDP), wherein you can invest in small monthly deposits
Pilgrims return to Mecca as Saudi Arabia eases coronavirus restrictions
2 min read . 01:49 PM IST- Despite taking early and sweeping measures to contain the virus, Saudi Arabia has recorded nearly 336,000 cases, including 4,850 deaths
- The Grand Mosque, which is being sterilized and cleaned multiple times a day, houses the cube-shaped Kaaba that observant Muslims pray toward five times a day
Vedanta’s profit tumbles as India lockdown hurts output, demand
1 min read . 11:51 AM IST- Vedanta’s main businesses include zinc, aluminum and oil and gas, all of which have been hit by a slump in demand due to the coronavirus pandemic
- Vedanta’s Hindustan Zinc, also Asia’s most valuable zinc producer, reported a 23% drop in June-quarter profit on lower prices and production
Kia Motors looks to ace SUV segment in India with Seltos, Sonet in tow
4 min read . 11:33 AM IST- Due to high demand, the waiting period for both Seltos and Sonet has gone up considerably
- Kia sold 9,266 units of Sonet in September thus getting the better of the likes of Hyundai Venue and Maruti Suzuki Vitara Brezza
Market cap of 8 of 10 most valued firms zooms ₹1.45 lakh crore
1 min read . 10:52 AM IST- The market valuation of Tata Consultancy Services (TCS) zoomed ₹37,692.7 crore to ₹9,46,632.85 crore, emerging as the biggest gainer among the top 10 firms
- In the ranking of top-10 firms, RIL remained at the number one rank
SBI Yono app update: Now, check balance, view passbook without logging in
2 min read . 10:57 AM IST- With pre-login features, SBI account holders can access their bank account details, view passbook and make transactions
- SBI had launched the Yono platform in November 2017 to help its customers' banking, investment and shopping needs
When billions in gold, cash were shifted by a central bank
1 min read . 10:33 AM IST- The Dutch central bank doesn't store all its gold in the Netherlands. It also has large reserves stored in the United States, Britain and Canada
- The cash and gold traveled about 20 km in trucks guarded by armed military police, police motorcycle outriders and with police helicopter hovering overhead
TCS earnings, global factors to dictate domestic markets this week: Analysts
1 min read . 10:14 AM IST- IT major TCS is scheduled to announce its number on October 7
- Analysts said PMI data for the services sector, movement in the rupee and Brent crude oil would be keenly watched by participants
Who will first get corona vaccine shot in India? Harsh Vardhan to reveal today
1 min read . 09:21 AM IST- Union Health Minister Harsh Vardhan will today give the details about India's coronavirus vaccine plan in Samvaad programme
- Vardhan earlier had said that a Covid-19 vaccine is likely to be available by the first quarter of 2021
India records 75,829 new cases and 940 deaths,total recoveries crosses 55 lakh
2 min read . 10:00 AM IST- With the single-day spike of 75,829 new covid-19 positive cases, India has reported total 65,49,374 cases
- The death toll due to coronavirus in the country rose to 1,01,782 after 940 deaths deaths due to covid-19 were reported in the last 24 hours
Gold paste worth ₹6.93 lakh seized from passenger at Chennai airport
1 min read . 11:02 AM IST- A passenger, who arrived from Dubai at Chennai International Airport, was intercepted & 2 bundles of gold paste were recovered
- 133 grams of gold worth at ₹6.93 lakhs was seized under Customs Act, 1962
IT companies to see improved revenues this quarter: ICICI Securities
2 min read . 09:11 AM ISTCost rationalisation by IT companies, lower travel cost, cross currency benefits and utilisation are expected to drive margins in the quarter.
Senior citizens bank FD rates at 8%. Check interest rates of 5 banks here
5 min read . 07:15 AM IST- Small finance banks offer higher FD interest rates to senior citizens
- A look at the FD interest rate offered by small finance banks like Suryoday. Fincare, Utkarsh, North East and Jana to senior citizens
India scales up testing capacity from 1 in January to over 7.7 cr in Oct: MoHFW
1 min read . 08:50 AM IST- The recovery rate of COVID-19 patients now stands at 83.84% and the total recoveries have surpassed the 54 lakh mark
- As per the MoHFW, 7,78,50,403 tests for COVID-19 were conducted in the country on October 3 which marks a new high
Donald Trump presses for stimulus deal, saying ‘get it done’
1 min read . 05:34 AM IST- US House Speaker Nancy Pelosi said Friday that negotiations with the White House will press ahead and Trump’s Covid-19 diagnosis might change the tenor of the talks by underscoring the seriousness of the pandemic
No comments:
Post a Comment